game·match

Games like Supernatural

If you love Supernatural, here are games with the same vibe, picked by taste similarity.

ActionAdventureIndie

REFINE

These picks come from one game: Supernatural.

Add 2 or 3 games from the same genre: we find what they share, and you sort the results with a swipe.

Refine from Supernatural

Free, no account. 3 tries a day.

24 games like Supernatural

Penumbra: Black Plague Gold Edition

Penumbra: Black Plague Gold Edition

Hidden gem
ActionAdventureIndie
Infliction

Infliction

Hidden gem
AdventureIndieHorror
The Bridge Curse 2: The Extrication

The Bridge Curse 2: The Extrication

Hidden gem
AdventureMysteryStory Rich
Unspoken

Unspoken

Hidden gem
ActionAdventureIndie
The Painscreek Killings

The Painscreek Killings

Hidden gem
AdventureIndieInvestigation
Fears to Fathom - Carson House

Fears to Fathom - Carson House

Hidden gem
AdventureCasualIndie
The Mortuary Assistant

The Mortuary Assistant

Hidden gem
AdventureIndieSimulation
SONG OF HORROR COMPLETE EDITION

SONG OF HORROR COMPLETE EDITION

Hidden gem
AdventureSurvival HorrorDark
The Case of the Golden Idol

The Case of the Golden Idol

Hidden gem
AdventureIndieMystery
Mists of Aiden

Mists of Aiden

Hidden gem
ActionAdventureIndie
Exit From

Exit From

Hidden gem
ActionAdventureIndie
SIMULACRA

SIMULACRA

Hidden gem
AdventureIndieSimulation
I'm on Observation Duty 5

I'm on Observation Duty 5

Hidden gem
IndieHorrorPsychological Horror
The Backrooms: Lost Tape

The Backrooms: Lost Tape

Hidden gem
ActionAdventureIndie
The Story of Henry Bishop

The Story of Henry Bishop

Hidden gem
ActionAdventureIndie
Dead Secret

Dead Secret

Hidden gem
AdventureIndiePsychological Horror
The Inheritance of Crimson Manor

The Inheritance of Crimson Manor

Hidden gem
AdventureIndieExploration
The Medium

The Medium

Hidden gem
AdventureHorrorFemale Protagonist
Welcome to Kowloon

Welcome to Kowloon

Hidden gem
AdventureIndieHorror
Enigma of Fear

Enigma of Fear

Hidden gem
ActionAdventureIndie
Emissary Zero

Emissary Zero

Hidden gem
AdventureIndieMassively Multiplayer
Is this Game Trying to Kill Me?

Is this Game Trying to Kill Me?

Hidden gem
ActionAdventureIndie
Pacify

Pacify

Hidden gem
ActionAdventureCasual
Who's Lila?

Who's Lila?

Hidden gem
AdventureCasualIndie

Not quite it? Add 2 or 3 games from the same genre as Supernatural to aim closer.

Refine from Supernatural

Explore more lists