Games like Pony Island
If you love Pony Island, here are games with the same vibe, picked by taste similarity.
24 resultsIndiePuzzlePsychological Horror
Not finding what you want? Sign in and we'll recommend games based on your own Steam library.
Sign in
I hate this game
Hidden gem
IndiePuzzlePixel Graphics
Please, Don’t Touch Anything
Hidden gem
CasualIndiePuzzle
Stephen's Sausage Roll
Hidden gem
IndiePuzzleDifficult
Filament
Hidden gem
IndieStrategyPuzzle
Divide By Sheep
Hidden gem
AdventureCasualIndie
Closure
Hidden gem
IndiePuzzlePlatformer
She Remembered Caterpillars
Hidden gem
IndiePuzzleHand-drawn
INMOST
Hidden gem
AdventureIndiePixel Graphics
The Room Three
Hidden gem
AdventureIndiePuzzle
Baba Is You
Hidden gem
IndiePuzzleDifficult
Angels of Death
Hidden gem
AdventureIndieRPG
OneShot: World Machine Edition
Hidden gem
AdventureCasualIndie
Press Ctrl
Hidden gem
IndiePuzzleDifficult
Mercury Abbey
Hidden gem
IndiePixel GraphicsPuzzle
Submachine: Legacy
Hidden gem
AdventureIndiePuzzle
Antichamber
Hidden gem
AdventureIndiePuzzle
Squishy the Suicidal Pig
Hidden gem
AdventureIndiePlatformer
Creaks
Hidden gem
AdventureCasualIndie
The Room Two
Hidden gem
AdventureIndiePuzzle
D'LIRIUM
Hidden gem
ActionAdventureIndie
Escape Goat
Hidden gem
ActionIndiePuzzle-Platformer
Awareness Rooms
Hidden gem
AdventureIndiePuzzle
klocki
Hidden gem
CasualIndiePuzzle
In Sound Mind
Hidden gem
ActionIndieHorror